Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer may eventually resign from his leadership role voluntarily rather than being forced out by his fellow Democrats, according to a seasoned political analyst.
Schumer has drawn ongoing criticism from members of his own party for his role in passing a Republican government funding bill that was nearly unanimously rejected by House Democrats. The New York senator once again dismissed calls for him to step down, stating on NBC’s Meet the Press on Sunday, “I’m not stepping down.”
Danielle Vinson, a professor of politics and international affairs at Furman University in South Carolina, told Newsweek that Schumer might be planning a “graceful exit” before his term concludes in January 2029, though he is unlikely to be forcibly “tossed out” as Senate leader.
Schumer has faced pressure to step down after he, along with eight Senate Democrats and independent Senator Angus King of Maine—who caucuses with the party—voted on March 14 to support a stopgap spending bill backed by President Donald Trump in order to avert a government shutdown.
There have also been suggestions that New York Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez should mount a primary challenge against Schumer, despite the fact that he is not up for reelection until 2028.
Ocasio-Cortez, nearly 40 years younger than Schumer, is frequently seen as a representative of a new generation of left-wing Democrats who should steer the party forward after the significant losses in the 2024 elections.
Vinson noted that the 74-year-old Schumer is likely aware of the mounting demand for new leadership within the party, and that calls for his resignation may intensify. The outcome of the 2026 midterms may see him further “encouraged and challenged” him to step down, depending on the results.
Sen. Michael Bennet (D-Colo.) said, “It’s important that people know when it’s time to go,” when asked about Schumer at a town hall in the town of Golden on March 17.
Rep. Glenn Ivey of Maryland stated on March 16 that it “may be time” for new Senate leadership after Schumer supported a continuing resolution that House Democrats nearly unanimously rejected.
Other analysts believe that the current state of the Democratic Party makes it ripe for the GOP to score unprecedented gains during the midterms, when the party in power historically loses congressional seats.
The public infighting “is not only a stunning display of ideological extremism, it is a public confirmation that the Democratic Party is severely splintered and beginning to self-destruct,’ notes Cooper Rummell in a piece for the Daily Signal. “It has no true leader, no clear agenda, and no solid path toward winning the 2026 midterms—which, from a political perspective, are quickly approaching.”
He added: “As progressives rebel against moderate Democrat leadership, the party as a whole is making an increasing number of political errors. Averting a government shutdown could have been an easy win for the Left. By putting country above party and reaching across the aisle, liberals could have launched a long-overdue rebrand. To actively push for a shutdown was both paradoxical and self-defeating, to say the least.”
House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries, D-N.Y., referred to the passage of the spending bill as an “assault on the economy, health care, the social safety net, and veterans.” Rummell noted that “the irony must be lost on him—because had he gotten his way, the shutdown he pushed for would have done just that.”
“Trump may occasionally pick fights with members of his own party, at the end of the day, Republicans still move in the same direction. Democrats, on the other hand, are flailing—leaderless, visionless, and increasingly irrelevant,” Rummell wrote.
He concluded: “Let Democrats continue to flail, and 2026 could be a repeat of last November. The Left is already unraveling—conservatives just have to make sure voters are paying attention.”